News Center
—— NEWS CENTER ——
Xi'an Shenghongchuang Instrument Co., Ltd.
Contact: Mr. Zhang
Mobile: 15529283736
Email: shc-sensor@qq.com
Address: Fortune Building, Sanqiao Street, Xixian New Area, Xi'an, Shaanxi Province
In storage tanks, water pools, sewage wells, chemical containers, and automated production lines, whether level data can be continuously and accurately transmitted to the control end directly affects processes such as alarms, interlocks, replenishment, and discharge. Xi'an Shenghongchuang wired level sensors and wireless solutions can both be used for level monitoring, but they differ significantly in communication paths, on-site installation, power supply methods, data stability, and subsequent maintenance costs.
For purchasing personnel and technical evaluators, comparing the quotation of a single product alone is not sufficient. A standard water tank located 30 meters from the control room and a group of distributed storage tanks located 3 kilometers from the central control platform require different sensor solutions. A comprehensive assessment should be made based on transmission distance, wiring difficulty, on-site electromagnetic environment, power supply conditions, and data real-time requirements.
Xi'an Shenghongchuang can provide wired outputs such as 4-20mA and RS485, as well as wireless transmission supporting solutions for remote data acquisition, to meet pressure-based, submersible, hydrostatic, and other level measurement requirements. For operating conditions involving high temperature, high pressure, corrosion, humidity, or strong interference, the sensor wetted material, protection rating, measurement range, and installation structure should also be included in the same selection logic.
The following explains the key differences between wired and wireless level sensors based on common issues in actual projects, helping project personnel reduce rework and avoid unstable signals and uncontrolled maintenance costs during the preliminary solution stage.
Wired level sensors typically transmit measurement signals to PLCs, DCSs, digital display controllers, or data acquisition modules through shielded cables. The commonly used 4-20mA signal in industrial sites has strong interference resistance and is suitable for applications requiring continuous control and real-time interlocking; RS485 communication facilitates networking multiple devices and reading digital parameters.
In factories where power supply conditions allow and cable routes are clear, wired solutions can usually achieve 24-hour continuous data acquisition. For systems with rapid level changes that require timely start-stop control of pump sets, millisecond- to second-level data response is easier to ensure, and the control logic is relatively straightforward.
The initial installation of wired solutions requires consideration of cable trays, conduits, waterproof connectors, and separation of power and signal circuits. If wiring passes near frequency converters, motors, or welding equipment, appropriate shielded cables and grounding measures should be used to prevent electromagnetic interference from causing signal fluctuations.
For projects involving new factory construction, simultaneous equipment upgrades and installation, or short distances between control cabinets and measurement points, wired level sensors generally offer good long-term cost efficiency. Although cables and installation labor represent an initial investment, battery life issues do not need to be handled frequently afterward.
Wireless level solutions typically consist of level sensors, wireless transmitter modules, receiving gateways, or cloud platforms. Measurement point data is uploaded via LoRa, NB-IoT, 4G, or other industrial wireless methods, making them suitable for sites where trenching and wiring are inconvenient, measurement points are dispersed, or upgrade schedules are tight.
For example, where there are multiple fire water pools, outdoor storage tanks, remote well locations, or temporary monitoring points within a plant, relaying hundreds of meters of cable to each measurement point may significantly increase installation costs and coordination difficulty. Wireless methods can reduce civil works and cable-laying tasks and improve deployment efficiency.
Wireless transmission does not mean there are no on-site condition limitations. Metal tanks, underground spaces, densely built areas, mountain obstructions, and strong electromagnetic environments can all affect communication quality. For equipment with nominal transmission distances of 1 kilometer, 3 kilometers, or even longer, actual on-site signal strength testing and network coverage results should still prevail.
Wireless devices also require attention to power sources. When powered by lithium batteries, reporting frequency, ambient temperature, and signal quality all affect battery life; when powered by solar energy or mains electricity, installation location, lightning protection measures, and power supply stability need to be assessed. For critical safety interlocks, relying solely on a single wireless link is generally not advisable.
The cost of wired solutions usually consists of sensors, signal cables, cable trays or protective conduits, installation labor, control cabinet modules, and other items. When the measurement point is within 50 meters and the site already has cable trays or reserved conduits, wired solutions are often easier to manage within the overall budget.
Wireless solutions can reduce the installation burden of long-distance trenching, wire pulling, and elevated wiring, but require additional costs for wireless terminals, gateways, communication cards, or platform services. For more than 10 measurement points located far apart, the marginal deployment cost after unified networking may offer greater advantages.
For procurement evaluation, it is recommended to calculate total cost of ownership over a service period of 3 to 5 years. In addition to the one-time purchase price, battery replacement, network fees, on-site inspections, fault troubleshooting, and shutdown risks should be included in the budget instead of judging cost-effectiveness only by the initial quotation.
For important storage tank level measurement, a reasonable approach is to configure on-site measurement, control signals, and remote management in layers. For example, use a local wired 4-20mA connection to the interlock system while uploading operating data through a gateway, thereby balancing control reliability and remote management efficiency.
For applications such as automatic water supply equipment, batching tanks, boiler make-up water tanks, and process storage tanks, level signals may be directly associated with pump set start-stop operations, valve control, or high- and low-level alarms. Wired outputs should be prioritized for such projects to ensure stable coordination with PLC logic.
If the measurement point is within 100 meters of the control cabinet and wiring can be installed in a standardized manner on site, 4-20mA is usually a practical choice. Its signal range is clearly defined, and abnormal conditions such as open circuits and short circuits are relatively easy to identify, making it suitable for most industrial automation control systems.
In areas with concentrated frequency converters and numerous motors, shielding measures, grounding methods, and cable routing should be confirmed. Signal cables should maintain reasonable separation from power cables, avoiding long-distance parallel routing of low-voltage signal cables and high-power cables.
For corrosive liquids or media containing impurities, wetted materials such as 316L stainless steel and PTFE should also be selected according to the medium characteristics. The sensor range should be matched with the installation depth to avoid overlooking the medium resistance of the sensing element simply because the communication method is appropriate.
For locations such as rainwater and sewage wells in industrial parks, dispersed water pools, outdoor silos, and temporary liquid storage points, wireless level monitoring can reduce repeated excavation and cross-area wiring. Especially in upgrade projects, avoiding damage to existing roads, flooring, and production operations has practical value.
Communication testing should be conducted first for wireless solutions. Underground wells, metal-sealed containers, and low-lying areas can easily create signal blind spots. If necessary, antennas can be installed at higher locations, or repeaters can be added and gateway installation points adjusted. Orders should not be placed based solely on theoretical transmission distances.
If the data is only used for viewing level trends, inventory counting, or over-limit notifications, timed reporting intervals of 5 minutes, 10 minutes, or 30 minutes can be set to reduce power consumption. If rapid alarms are required, the upload interval should be shortened while reassessing power endurance and communication traffic.
For unattended areas, low battery level, communication interruption, and sensor fault status are recommended to be incorporated into platform alarms simultaneously. With only level values and no device health status, it is difficult to promptly determine later whether "no data" means that the level is stable or that the terminal is offline.
When consulting Xi'an Shenghongchuang about a level sensor solution, it is recommended to clearly specify the medium name, level range, vessel height, temperature, pressure, density, and whether corrosion, deposits, or foam are present. Taking a 0-5 meter range as an example, if the actual level fluctuates only between 0.5 meters and 1 meter for an extended period, selecting an excessively large range may affect effective resolution.
The on-site control method should also be explained, including whether connection to a PLC is required, whether an on-site digital display is needed, whether remote viewing on mobile phones or computers is required, and whether alarms should be delivered by audible and visual signals, SMS, or platform push notifications. Different data usage methods determine the configuration of output signals, communication protocols, and supporting instruments.
For wireless projects, provide the actual distance between measurement points and the gateway, building obstructions, whether the equipment is located underground or inside metal containers, and whether 4G, NB-IoT, or enterprise network conditions are already available on site. Preliminary site surveys can identify communication risks in advance and prevent frequent disconnections after installation.
Overall, wired level sensors are suitable for fixed applications with high requirements for real-time performance, stability, and control linkage; wireless level sensors are suitable for applications with dispersed measurement points, difficult wiring, and clear needs for centralized remote management. On-site operating conditions, measurement range, installation method, transmission distance, and control requirements can be organized and submitted to Xi'an Shenghongchuang technical personnel to obtain matching product models, wiring recommendations, and an overall measurement and control configuration solution.
Related Recommendations